Men’s Keen Targhee IV WP Review

Bottom Line

The KEEN Targhee IV WP is a crowd-pleaser when it comes to traction, a roomy toe box, and overall stability. These shoes have been on our Best Hiking Shoes for Men guide for years. Senior Gear Analyst Ian Krammer tested the Targhee IVs on dozens of hikes in the Colorado foothills up to 12,000 feet and found they’re a good choice for rugged, technical backcountry conditions. They are reliably waterproof, and the lacing system still allows a fairly snug fit. The Targhee IV also earned above-average marks for durability, lasting multiple seasons with minimal maintenance. When the trail is a bit muddy, the weather forecast looks iffy, or we’re hiking in shoulder season, the Targhee IV is a solid pick for many feet.

However, they are heavier than most of the competition, have stiffer soles, and require a longer break-in period, too. This is a welcome combination for heavier backpacking loads and more technical trails, but they can feel bulky and excessive on flat and gentler trails. These shoes also have one of the highest heel-to-toe drops of any shoe we’ve reviewed, at 14mm, which won’t work for low drop fans. We like their burly construction and protective features, but the leather uppers and lack of mesh paneling means these shoes can run hot in warm conditions. This KEEN model is best suited for hikers seeking durable, comfortable, and stable footwear for challenging trails in spring, fall and cooler conditions.

Comfort

The KEEN Targhee IV WP hiking shoe is a comfortable choice when taking on rugged, technical trails with a medium to heavier backpack. Our testing showed they thrive in cooler conditions and muddy, unpredictable weather. Gear Analyst Ian Krammer’s first 100 miles in these shoes were on wet, snowy spring conditions in the Front Range of Colorado. He found they were uncomfortable to start due to their longer break-in period. It took around 20 to 25 miles before they softened up and felt more comfortable. That said, their durable, pliable leather uppers molded to his feet over time to fit like a glove. 

The longest hike we’ve tested these shoes on was the Skyline Traverse, a tough 16-mile route summiting five peaks above Boulder, Colorado. This trail offers a comprehensive test for any footwear with packed trail, plenty of rocks and roots, and the occasional scramble. We found the generously cushioned insoles and midsoles excelled at absorbing shock and providing good support throughout the day. Ian’s testing highlighted a standout feature of the Targhee IVs: a sturdy band that connects the laces to the heel cup, creating a secure and locked-in fit for uneven terrain and moderate ascents and descents. Coupled with an oversized protective toe cap and a durable heel cup, these shoes deliver reliable comfort and protection.

Ian’s narrower feet made the Targhee IV’s wide toe box feel a bit too roomy, but this was solved by tightening the laces and wearing thicker socks. Hikers with average or wider feet are less likely to encounter this issue. We really appreciate the substantial arch support and slightly pliable midsole, which allow your foot to flex naturally during ascents and on technical terrain.

Hikers who prefer low drop or zero drop footwear should skip the KEEN Targhee IV. Its heel-to-toe drop is a whopping 14 mm, which is the highest of any shoes we’ve tested. Overall, though, we ranked it high for comfort.

Traction

If you’re looking for seriously sticky traction, the KEEN Targhee IV is a solid choice for varied terrain and moderate inclines. The multi-directional lug pattern through the center of the foot reliably grips on almost any dry surface, including soft sand and gravel, packed dirt, and rocks. Plus, the tread pattern sheds debris easily. In our experience, the shoe’s tread design worked well on milder inclines, but isn’t as effective for biting into the ground.

Ian Krammer wore the Targhee IV to summit 14,271’ Quandary Peak in Colorado, which has a moderate, packed-dirt Class 2 trail to the top. The lugs, though fairly shallow and wide, felt stable on established routes like this, and the wide soles made him feel confident over mixed trail conditions. On the downside, the Targhee IV’s traction fell a bit short on steep inclines and declines and felt less sure-footed on wet or slippery surfaces like slick roots and rocks

This was glaringly obvious when climbing a more technical trail in Rocky Mountain National Park to the rugged and remote Frozen Lake. We noted this shoe’s traction limitations when braking on steep descents and crawling up sharp ascents. There’s a wide, steep slick area of about 200 feet to climb before reaching the banks of the lake at 11,600’, and after a couple of slips, we opted to stay on all fours both heading up and down to avoid another fall. That said, these aren’t dealbreakers, but you’ll want to be a bit more careful when crossing wet zones or taking on lots of vert.

Weight

There’s no way around it: the KEEN Targhee IV WP is the heaviest hiking shoe on our list at 2 pounds, 6.4 ounces for the pair. The reason it’s a bit heavier is its build: Targhees feature bombproof leather uppers and burly outsoles made from a durable rubber composite. 

That being said, Senior Gear Analyst didn’t notice this extra weight when wearing a weighted pack over tougher terrain. On a training hike on the Skyline Traverse, these shoes were a good pick since the stiffer soles and robust construction helped support the extra weight and reduce strain on the rockiest sections. Compared to the other hiking shoes and trail runners in our guide, however, the Targhee IV is a bit heavy and cumbersome. If you mostly hike on gentler trails with lighter loads, or you’re looking for more nimble, breathable footwear, you may want to consider lighter hiking shoes or trail runners instead. If you prioritize durability and support over ultralight construction, these shoes are the ticket.

Durability

These shoes are made with quality materials that give them decent durability. With sturdy all-leather uppers that offer robust protection against abrasions, rocks, and other trail hazards, complemented by double-stitched panels along the outsoles, the Targhee is built to last. The downside of such burly leather uppers is they require some maintenance, including waterproof treatment and cleaning.

Our gear analyst’s favorite feature of these shoes is the thick, wide toe cap. He’s kicked rocks, navigated long talus fields, and bushwhacked through thick aspen forests, and found this rubber endures hundreds of miles of tough backcountry environments. Since the toe cap is fused to the shoe – not glued – the rubber won’t delaminate over time. We’ve also found the lugs are fairly slow to wear down. The rubber composite has performed admirably, even after dozens of rocky trails and boulder field crossings.

Senior Gear Analyst Ian Krammer has put 250 miles on his Targhees in remote backcountry routes high in the Colorado Rockies, and they are just now beginning to show wear and tear. The lugs have worn down, one of the leather panels has begun to separate on the outside of the shoe, the laces are fraying where the knot is tied, and two of the four webbed eyelets are beginning to blow out. That said, no shoe lasts forever, and he expects to get many more miles out of these shoes before they’re retired.

Weather Resistance

For folks hiking in cool, wet, and unexpected weather conditions in the fall, spring, and even mild winter conditions, the KEEN Targhee IV is a no-brainer. Gear Analyst Ian Krammer tested these shoes in both rainy and snowy spring conditions in the Colorado foothills, where their waterproof construction and leather uppers effectively kept water out. In mid-April he took on the Skyline Traverse above Boulder, Colorado, in mid-April. The trails were full of ice, lingering snow, and puddles – plus it was spitting rain most of the day – yet the Targhee IV kept his feet dry.

However, these shoes’ lower ankle design means they’re more prone to taking on water, and they can take many hours to dry once wet. For especially wet routes, you may want to consider wearing a pair of water resistant ankle gaiters or waterproof hiking pants to block moisture. Or, simply upgrade to the mid-cut Targhee IV for better weather protection.

This model’s waterproof construction comes from its waterproof leather uppers, a waterproof liner, and protective rubber rand. This design not only blocked out water, but kept our feet feeling warm in temperatures below 45°F. The shoe’s ability to repel moisture and retain a bit of warmth makes them über versatile across different seasons and terrain. By the same token, the Targhee IV isn’t our favorite in hot summer weather. Our gear analyst reported hot spots and a large blister on both heels after hiking 11 hours at Utah’s San Rafael Swell on an 80°F October day. 

Should You Buy the Keen Targhee IV WP?

The KEEN Targhee IV is a reliable pick for hikers who want a dependable, roomy, and durable shoe for challenging and soggy backcountry conditions. With good traction for moderate terrain, a secure lacing system, and a roomy toe box, these shoes offer strong comfort for long hikes in rain, snow, and mud. However, their heavier weight, higher heel-to-toe drop, and longer break-in period may not suit folks seeking lightweight or low-drop hiking shoes. The waterproofing is effective but can easily lead to overheating in warmer conditions. If you need a long-lasting, supportive shoe for rugged terrain and cooler climates, the KEEN Targhee IV is a top pick.

What Other Hiking Shoes Should You Consider?

If you’re not sold on the KEEN Targhee IV WP, please stroll over to our guides to the Best Hiking Shoes for Men to see our full list of recommendations. 

Merrell Moab 3 Review: The Merrell Moab 3 is a great alternative with its similar aesthetic, dependable traction, and roomy fit. However, the Moab has more flexible soles and is more suitable for warmer climates. 

HOKA Anacapa 2 Low GTX Review: The HOKA Anacapa shares the Targhee IV’s excellent support and waterproofing, but it’s much more comfortable – especially if you want a plush and cushy ride. 

La Sportiva Spire GTX Review: The La Sportiva Spire GTX also offers superb traction and durability like the Targhee IV. However, these feel more like a traditional boot underfoot.