Table of contents

Columbia Amaze Puff Hooded Jacket Review

Tested by: Meghan Allsopp

We independently test everything we recommend.
Buying through links on our site supports our work.

We are a reader-supported website and do not accept payment from manufacturers to promote their products. When you click on some of the links on our site and make a purchase, we earn a small commission at no cost to you. This keeps our website running and enables us to provide independent, high-quality outdoor resources free of charge.
Alt text: Close-up of a light blue puffy jacket’s sleeve, shoulder, and snapped high collar, dotted with tiny water droplets, with a golden larch behind.

Bottom Line

The Columbia Amaze Puff Hooded Jacket is an inviting everyday down puffer for people who want warmth and comfort without a long parka. We felt comfortably warm during winter walks in Montana, even with the hood removed. Its 650-fill down and generously insulated collar make the hip-length design feel substantial despite its shorter cut.

Little details distinguish it from a basic puffer. The deep, fleece-lined pockets were among the softest we’ve handled, while stretchy cuffs with thumbholes added welcome hand coverage. We could remove the hood quickly using its snaps, and the front zipper and closures felt easy to operate.

The design isn’t without distractions. Removable interior carrying straps let the coat hang from your shoulders like a backpack, but they occasionally caught our arms when we were hastily putting the jacket on. The fabric also snagged in the zipper once, although it stretched free without tearing. For cold commuting and short winter walks, the lush comfort is the main attraction; for extended wet weather or coverage below the hips, browse our best winter jackets for women guide for more protective options.

How We Tested

We wore the Amaze Puff on walks in Montana and BC. We noted warmth while moving, how the removable hood and oversized collar worked well together, and the feel and depth of the hand pockets. We also checked the wrist coverage, snaps, front zipper, and the stretchy shell after a zipper snag.

We assessed the removable carrying straps feature during everyday wear and found them not our cup of tea (but if you were popping in and out of stores in the city, yes this would be a dream.

Quick Specs

Bright red hooded insulated puffer jacket with wide horizontal baffles against a plain white background.

Columbia Amaze Puff Hooded Jacket

Coziest Short Down Jacket

CleverHiker Rating: 4.5/5.0

Price: $220

Weight: n/a

Insulation: 650-fill-power down

Length: 23 in.

Pros

  • Plush fleece-lined pockets
  • Cozy insulated collar
  • Removable hood
  • Thumbhole cuffs
  • Stretchy shell fabric
  • Removable backpack straps for carrying
  • So many color options

Cons

  • Shorter coverage
  • Not waterproof
  • Shell fabric can snag in zipper
  • Discolors easily
The CleverHiker Budget Buy Badge Logo with a down jacket picture in the middle
A woman in a green cap wears a light blue puffy jacket with the hood up and a hand at the zipper near her chin, on a snowy road lined with evergreens, while a brown dog sniffs the snow at right.
The tall hood and collar wrap the head and neck like a blanket. – Photo Credit: Meghan Allsopp (CleverHiker.com)

Warmth

The Amaze Puff impressed us most with its immediate coziness. We were comfortably warm in 30-degrees and 20 MPH winds and the high, well-insulated collar provided enough coverage that we preferred removing the hood for that outing. For someone heading out in chilly fall or winter weather, that removable layer keeps the jacket from feeling unnecessarily bundled around the head. But we’ve been very glad to have it when we want to trap as much of our body heat as possible. 

Columbia uses 650-fill-power down, and the jacket is designed with room for a sweater or sweatshirt underneath. The 23-inch length also leaves more of the lower body exposed than a knee-length parka, but the cinchable waist hem and cuff gaiters do a good job of keeping your core warm and trapping precious body heat.

Close-up of a woman wearing a light blue puffy jacket with the hood up and a tall, snapped collar zipped to her chin, with soft-focus snowy trees behind her.
The high collar and hood that cinches add serious warmth. – Photo Credit: Meghan Allsopp (CleverHiker.com)

Weather Resistance

The shell is made for damp, changeable weather rather than an all-day storm. Columbia’s Omni-Shield treatment is water and stain repellent, not a waterproof membrane, and the hood and adjustable hem offer additional ways to close gaps. Those are useful safeguards for a quick outing in light precipitation, but we don’t grab this jacket when we anticipate sustained rain exposure.

The inside lining of the jacket absorbs water without hesitation, so it’s a good reminder to ditch the jacket if you start sweating to keep those lofty feathers afloat.

Weather Resistance Score: 4.4 / 5.0

Alt text: Close-up of the inside of a light blue jacket’s hood, speckled with water spots, with two snaps and a drawcord toggle visible, lying on grass.
A comparison of how the exterior beads moisture, but the interior does the opposite. – photo credit: meghan allsopp (cleverhiker.com)

Comfort & Functionality

The hand pockets made the strongest first impression. They’re deep and generously lined with soft fleece, so putting cold hands inside feels much more pleasant than in an ordinary down jacket. The puffy collar is equally cozy, and the removable hood gives us the choice of full coverage or a less bulky neckline.

Stretchy cuffs with thumbholes extend over our hands without requiring separate wrist gaiters. We also liked the give in the outer fabric when moving and handling the jacket. The cut lands at the hip rather than mid-thigh, which can be convenient for mobility but doesn’t surround the legs with warmth the way a long parka does. 

All in all, this jacket performs more like a premium option than an entry budget buy.

Comfort & Functionality Score: 4.8 / 5.0

Close-up of a light blue puffy jacket at the waist, showing a hand resting on the hip, the elastic sleeve cuff, and a drawcord tab hanging from the hem, with snowy trees blurred behind.
A solid zipper with an insulated storm flap, cinchable hem, and generous cuffs keeps the cold out and the warmth in. – photo credit: meghan allsopp (cleverhiker.com)

Features

Several thoughtful features help justify choosing this over a plain down puffer. The snap-off hood is easy to remove, the thumbhole cuffs cover more of the wrist, and the zippered fleece-lined hand pockets keep small essentials close. It also has an fleece-lined interior security pocket and adjustable hem, which add practical organization and fit control.

The unusual addition is a set of removable shoulder straps intended to carry the jacket on your back indoors. We initially left them installed, but our arms occasionally ended up on the wrong side of the straps when we threw it on in a hurry, so we’d take them out for normal wear. Frequent transitions between warm buildings and cold streets are the use case in which that system makes the most sense.

Features Score: 4.7 / 5.0

woman in a green cap and tan sweater holds her arms straight out to the sides, with a light blue puffy jacket pulled partway off her shoulders, on a snowy dirt road lined with snow-covered evergreens.
This jacket functions easily and is so soft and comfortable it’s claim of extreme coziness is affirmed in our testing. – photo credit: meghan allsopp (cleverhiker)

Should You Buy the Columbia Amaze Puff Hooded JAcket?

Choose this jacket if you want a stylish, soft, cozy warmth for daily winter routines and don’t need the length of a full parka. Our short cold-weather walks confirmed that the insulated collar, plush pockets, and covered wrists make a tangible difference in comfort. We especially liked being able to remove the hood without sacrificing warmth around the neck.

Look elsewhere if your priority is a fully waterproof shell, coverage over your thighs, or a more technical design for activities beyond winter walks and cool-weather hangs. Oh, and it comes in a million lovely colorways.

Alt text: A woman in a navy beanie and a light blue puffy jacket looks down, standing beside a golden larch tree in a grassy meadow.
A hem drawcord and high collar help you dial in the fit on chilly fall days. – Photo Credit: Meghan Allsopp (CleverHiker.com)

What Other Winter Jackets Should You Consider?

Take a look at our list of the best winter jackets for women or read more about specific similar models:

The North Face Hydrenalite Review: Very similar in length, but with less puff and an attached hood and no adjustment to the hem, this is a simpler and fantastic option if you don’t think you’ll need as much down warmth or wrapped in a blanket vibe.

REI Stormhenge 850 Hybrid Parka Review: Consider the Stormhenge when cold, wet weather is a bigger concern than a soft, casual feel. Its weather-focused construction is a more appropriate starting point for sustained wintry precipitation; the Amaze Puff favors easy daily comfort and a simpler short-jacket silhouette.

Arc’teryx Atom Hoody Review: The Atom is the more active-minded option for hiking or other higher-output use, with synthetic insulation and more freedom to regulate heat while moving. Choose the Amaze Puff when plush down warmth and a cozy collar are more useful than a lightweight technical layering piece.

A hiker wearing the light blue Women's Columbia Amaze Puff Hooded Jacket adjusts the front zipper while standing on a snow-dusted trail surrounded by evergreen trees.
The main front zipper on the Columbia Amaze Puff Hooded Jacket operates smoothly without catching on the draft flap, making temperature adjustments effortless on cold winter trails. – Photo Credit: Meghan Allsopp (CleverHiker.com)